The criminal solicitor role: seven stages of support from arrest to verdict
SaveA criminal solicitor provides legal advice, representation and advocacy throughout criminal proceedings. Their work begins the moment you are arrested or invited for interview, and continues through charging decisions, court appearances and sentencing. This guide explains what a criminal solicitor does at each stage, what you can expect from them, and where your own decisions remain yours to make. HS Criminal Law sets out the solicitor's duties so you know what support is available.
Representation at the police station
Your solicitor attends the police station when you are held for questioning. They meet you privately before any interview to explain what the police have disclosed, what offence is suspected, and what your options are. During the interview itself, the solicitor sits beside you and can intervene if a question is unclear, repetitive or oppressive.
They advise on whether to answer questions or provide a prepared statement. That decision is yours, but the solicitor explains the implications of each choice. If you choose silence, they ensure the police understand you are exercising your right, not admitting guilt. Their presence alone often changes how the interview is conducted.
Early advice on charges and bail
After interview, the police decide whether to charge you, release you under investigation, or take no further action. Your solicitor argues against charge where the evidence does not meet the threshold, and negotiates bail conditions if you are released pending further enquiries. Conditions might include residence requirements, curfews or restrictions on contact.
Where the police refer the case to the Crown Prosecution Service for a charging decision, the solicitor can make representations on your behalf. They explain what each possible charge means, the maximum sentence it carries, and what happens next. This is often when you learn whether your case will be heard in the magistrates court or Crown Court.
The difference legal advice makes early
Solicitors catch procedural errors that might later exclude evidence. They identify weaknesses in the police case before it hardens into a prosecution file. Early advice shapes the whole trajectory of your case, and mistakes made in the first hours are difficult to undo later.
Case preparation and disclosure review
Between charge and trial, your solicitor builds your defence. They request disclosure from the prosecution: witness statements, CCTV, forensic reports, interview transcripts. They check that disclosure is complete and challenge omissions. Material the prosecution does not intend to use can still support your case, and the solicitor knows what to ask for.
They take a full statement from you, gather evidence that supports your account, and identify witnesses who can speak for you. If expert evidence is needed – on identification, forensics or phone data – the solicitor instructs that expert and ensures their report is ready for court. Every piece of your defence is documented and served on the prosecution within the deadlines the court sets.
Building the defence strategy
Your solicitor analyses the prosecution case for gaps, inconsistencies and legal weaknesses. They advise on whether the evidence against you is strong or contestable, and what defences might apply. This is also when you discuss the question of plea: whether to accept the charges or contest them. The guilty plea decision affects sentence length, trial preparation and your options going forward.
Court representation and advocacy
In the magistrates court, a solicitor can represent you throughout. At Crown Court, a solicitor may instruct a barrister to advocate, though solicitors with higher rights of audience can appear themselves. Either way, your solicitor briefs the advocate, attends hearings, and remains your main point of contact.
The solicitor or barrister speaks on your behalf at every hearing: bail applications, plea hearings, trial and sentencing. They cross-examine prosecution witnesses, call your witnesses, make legal submissions and object to inadmissible evidence. You do not speak directly to the judge or magistrates unless you give evidence from the witness box; your legal team speaks for you.
| Stage | Who represents you | What they do |
|---|---|---|
| Magistrates court | Solicitor or barrister | Full representation, advocacy, cross-examination |
| Crown Court | Barrister (instructed by solicitor) | Trial advocacy, jury addresses, legal argument |
| Sentencing | Solicitor or barrister | Mitigation, character references, sentence proposals |
| Appeal | Barrister (often different counsel) | Grounds of appeal, legal submissions, fresh evidence |
Negotiation with the prosecution
Criminal defence is not only about trial. Your solicitor negotiates with the Crown Prosecution Service throughout the case. They discuss charge reduction: accepting a lesser offence in return for dropping a more serious one. They propose alternative charges where the facts support them. They argue for discontinuance where the evidence has weakened.
This work happens out of court, often by letter or phone. A skilled solicitor knows when the prosecution will move and when they will not. The goal is always the best outcome for you, whether that means avoiding conviction altogether, securing a non-custodial sentence, or reducing the harm of a guilty verdict.
Sentencing and mitigation
If you are convicted or plead guilty, your solicitor prepares mitigation: the case for the lowest possible sentence. They present character references, employment records, evidence of remorse and steps you have taken since the offence. They explain personal circumstances that make custody disproportionate or a community order more appropriate.
The solicitor addresses the court on sentencing guidelines, culpability and harm. They propose specific sentences – a fine rather than community order, a suspended sentence rather than immediate custody – and explain why each is justified. Where a pre-sentence report is ordered, the solicitor ensures probation has the full picture. Understanding probation orders and other community sentences helps you prepare for what the court might impose.
What mitigation cannot do
Mitigation reduces the sentence within the range the offence allows. It does not erase the conviction or override mandatory minimum sentences. Your solicitor is honest about what is possible and what is not, so you are not surprised by the outcome.
Advice on appeals and further proceedings
After sentence, your solicitor advises on whether you have grounds to appeal your conviction or sentence. They explain the time limits, the process and the realistic prospects of success. If an appeal is justified, they instruct an appellate barrister and ensure the grounds are filed on time.
Where you are subject to a court order – a restraining order, a sexual harm prevention order or another restriction – your solicitor explains what it prohibits and the consequences of breach. If circumstances change and the order is no longer appropriate, they can apply for variation or discharge.
Your decisions and your solicitor's duties
A solicitor advises, but you decide. The decision to plead guilty or not guilty is yours. The decision to give evidence at trial is yours. The decision to appeal is yours. Your solicitor sets out the options, the risks and the likely consequences, but they do not make those choices for you.
The solicitor's duty is to act on your instructions, represent your interests and keep your communications confidential. They cannot mislead the court, but they do not judge you. Even where they personally believe a different course of action is wiser, they follow your lawful instructions.
When you disagree with your solicitor
If you and your solicitor cannot agree on the conduct of your case, you can instruct a different solicitor. Legal aid transfers between firms, and privately funded clients can change representation at any time. The new solicitor takes over the file and continues from where the last one left off. Changing solicitor close to trial can delay proceedings, but it is your right.
Steps to take when you instruct a solicitor
- Ask for a solicitor as soon as you are arrested or invited for interview, and do not answer questions until they arrive.
- Give your solicitor a full and honest account of events, including facts that seem unhelpful – they need the whole picture to advise you properly.
- Provide documents, names and contact details for witnesses as soon as you can, so the solicitor can gather evidence before memories fade.
- Attend every meeting and court hearing your solicitor arranges, and read every letter and document they send you.
- Tell your solicitor immediately if your circumstances change – if you move address, lose your job, or are arrested again – because it affects bail, sentence and your defence.
If you are looking for representation and do not yet have a solicitor, the guide on finding a criminal solicitor explains what credentials to check and what questions to ask. For those approaching their first court date, six stages between arrest and magistrates court sets out what happens in the weeks before you appear.
This article is for general information only. It does not constitute legal advice for your specific situation.
Download PDF: Working with your criminal solicitor: a practical checklist PDF, 29 KB
Further reading
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a solicitor and a barrister in criminal cases?
A solicitor manages your case, advises you, prepares your defence and instructs experts. A barrister is a specialist advocate who represents you at Crown Court trial, though solicitors with higher rights can also appear. Your solicitor remains your main contact throughout.
Can I represent myself instead of using a criminal solicitor?
You have the right to represent yourself in criminal proceedings, but it is rarely advisable. The law, procedure and rules of evidence are complex, and mistakes can lead to conviction or a harsher sentence. Free legal advice is available at the police station and through legal aid for those who qualify.
How much does criminal legal representation cost?
If you are questioned at a police station, legal advice is always free regardless of your income. For court proceedings, legal aid covers representation if you meet the financial and interests-of-justice tests. If you do not qualify, solicitors charge privately, and you should ask for a clear estimate at the first meeting.